[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]
Library Catalogs
ACORN
KUDZU 
ATHENA
WorldCat
Other Catalogs
 
Databases
Articles & Databases
E-Journal Locator
Find an Article
E-Books
Reference Tools
Government Info
Internet Search Engines
 
Services
Renew Materials
Interlibrary-Loan
Find Reserves
Place On Reserve
Copyright Clearance
Request Forms
Computers
 
Research Assistance
?Ask Us
Getting Started
Find an Article
Find Theses/Dissertations
Subject Guides
Subject Librarians
 

What is the difference between popular magazines and scholarly journals?

 
Popular Magazines
Scholarly Journals
Appearance
Glossy paper, advertisements, heavily illustrated, attractive in appearance
Sober and serious, may contain graphs or charts, will not find glossy pages or photographs
Audience
General Public
Scholars and students
Authors
Reporters
Scholars in the field
Documentation
Sources sometimes cited for news articles, but rarely
Cite sources in footnotes or bibliography
Purpose
Provide general information
Report on original research or experimentation
Article Acceptance
Procedure
Articles written by hired reporters, edited by magazine editors, and published
Often undergo a "peer-reviewed" process -- reviewed by other scholars in the field before being published. Sometimes these journals are called "refereed journals"


Updated August 2002
R. Stringer-Hye
Campus Libraries: Biomedical | Central | Divinity | Law | Management | Music | Peabody | Science & Engineering | Special Collections | TV News
Vanderbilt University | Phone Numbers/Addresses of Campus Libraries | Privacy Policy
Jean and Alexander Heard Library, 419 21st Avenue South, Nashville, TN 37203-2427
Telephone 615-322-7100 | Fax 615-343-8279